Julian Dibbell in "Play Money" noted this exact clause when he started selling his farmed gold on eBay. He contacted eBay and asked if he could send them a piece of paper, entitling them to him handing the gold over. He likened it to the sale of a concert ticket; you gain nothing from the ticket but the agreement that you will be given the right to see a concert. You don't actually receive anything physical bar the ticket, so there is no reason he couldn't send out tickets for gold.

They said no, unsurprisingly, but he was perfectly correct. eBay should either rewrite the policy, or allow it to take place, as long as some physical good is transferred.

Reply

Oops, read it wrong. Dibbell didn't refer to this at all. My bad.

I think it is a stretch to consider gold "intellectual property" though.

Reply

Maybe this will force a kind of underground game-item-selling-ebay just for this kind of stuff? Then maybe when that is busted down it will fracture into thousands of smaller ones.

*starts thinking up site name for all the money I'm going to make*

Reply

All history reveals over and over again...That's just words for the press. The fact of the matter is...they make tons of fees for the transactions of "nothing" via automated systems that only the users do any real work for. Between auction commissions and the outrageous fees paypal charges...that makes free money for investor's pockets. There's always that "selling their time invested" work-around that there is no legal justification for canceling people's auctions. So, obviously any respectable business person from ebay will allow it to go on. Maybe cancel a few auctions here and there to make Blizzard reps happy. But the reality of it is that Blizzard cannot take any legal action to prevent it so as long as the dough rolls in, auctions will continue. It's basic capitalism.

Reply

Blizzard runs a highly successful game. Leeching profits and destroying the economy, the "farming mafia" - that's all those criminal gold sellers, level services etc - severely damage the game experience for the majority of honest players.

Gold farmers / sellers = criminals
Gold buyers = cheaters

Who'd be so %&$§ as to cheat in an online game? ANYONE who bought WoW gold deserves to be banned for life.

Reply

@Yotix (Comment #5)
Agreed, buying gold is akin to cheating, and those that do so should be punished.

However, there is one sad truth to the hot topic of gold buying. Pre-BC there was much speculation that many of the guilds learning end-game content were buying gold in troves. The rational of this, was that high repair costs, farming for materials and other money sinks were forcing many guilds to purchase gold to cover the costs.

IF (caps intentional) this was/is the case, then Blizzard would (ie:should) have to ban said members. There have been a few instances of entire guilds being banned (one of the most notorious, for hacking), and this has created much drama. Does Blizzard care about drama? Not so much, and community outcry isn't going to change their minds either.

I believe that Blizzard has decided to combat the Gold selling problems at the initial source, the farmers and sellers. While admirable, this is fruitless. That policy just forces the farmers/sellers into buying more accounts (ie: more $$$ for Blizzard). I think perma-banning credit cards would help circumvent some of this. Also, gold buyers should receive temporary bans, starting in hourly denominations and moving towards days/weeks and a perma-ban.

Further on the topic of selling in-game IP/items, the content-publishers selling items. Sony tried it, and it didn't make a splash in the bucket. Blizzard and Upper Deck have tried it with exclusive items, limited to loot cards and points received from the CCG. I think this may be a step in the right direction. Offer cool exclusives to those who will pay, as long as the items and prices aren't outrageous.

Reply

@ #6

I disagree with your comments on end-game guilds having to buy gold.

Sure, some members of these guilds buy gold just to keep up with their peers. Usually due to not having enough time to be in-game. For the most part though, you'd be amazed how many hours the really dedicated players will put into this game to farm materials to supply the guild for a night of raiding. Multple alts strictly for farming herbs, ore, enchant materials, etc. etc. It all adds up, and as long as a few smart people run the guild and manage the guild bank, there is no need to buy gold.

Reply

@ #7

Look at what #6 is saying..."guilds learning end-game content"
...not your definition of "end-game guilds" that would amaze you by "how many hours the really dedicated players will put into this game to farm materials to supply the guild for a night of raiding".

#6 is implying these are the non-hardcore players who are behind everyone else. It makes perfect sense as the non-hardcore players probably have jobs/life obligations other than “The Guild” and hence little time but a lot of money.

Thinks of it this way…the average “real player” can farm X gold/hour. The average industrialized worker can buy the same X gold for less than minimum wage. Considering that many industrialized workers actually earn many times minimum wage…there rest of the story is a no-brainer. Who’s “smarter” now? The player who farms…or the player who buys? Now that’s a little murkier, isn’t it? ;)

Reply

Second life is exempt presumably because its terms of service provide its users with intellectual property rights over the diginal content they create, including distribution rights, and so auctions do not run afoul of ebay's policy.

Reply

"farming mafia"

LOL

Reply

You are correct, SL players owns the IP for what they create.

Reply

Oh my, what a slipperly slope this is.

First, Blizzard is now officially selling in-game items for cash. Did you miss it? It's called the World of Warcraft Trading Card Game. Despite its secondary nature (supposedly playing the card game is the primary value) it is establishing a cash for item trade.

Second, is buying or farming gold cheating? Why so exactly? If I start a new character on a new server and my buddy hands me 10 gold to get me started (bags, starting gear, etc.) is that cheating? Why not? If I buy him lunch in the real world for his troubles, does that makes it cheating? What if I just give him $5? See the slope?

The only way to eliminate this secondary market is to eliminate the trading of gold. Drop the ability to trade it between players or to send it in mail. And the AH has to go too - otherwise. Of course, that eliminates the primary market, and I doubt we actually want that.

Time and time again, people have found that if a strong primary market exists for a commodity, a secondary market can and will grow up around it. These are facts - it's hard to imagine a way to get rid of it.

Reply

Good about time. People like gold farmers need to be controlled.

Reply