i took up asking for a tip for combines simply because i got sick and tired of having to haggle with people over what i considered fair value.

unfortunately for me, most of my combines seem to revolve aroun going to BRD, solo'ing incendius and crafting stuff at the black forge. and for the record: anything less than 50g for that sort of stuff is a lousy tip, imo.

Reply

I'll usually drop a tip to the rogue who is offering to pick boxes for free. I figure that I get a little something, he gets a little something, and its all good.

Reply

Depending on what it is, I've tipped anywhere from 50s up to 5-10g. However, of late, I find that all I'm really getting done are higher level craft combines, and in those cases, I'll let the crafter keep the extra mats. The exception to that being enchanting, since I have a hard enough time coming by mats to get that type of stuff done as it is.

Reply

I usually tip a pot or two. Or something like a couple of armor kits. They can either use or sell in AH or to vendor.

Reply

I almost never give gold as a tip. I am an Alchemist, so depending on thier class and level I will make them a couple potions. I have never had anyone complain, so it seems to work for me.

Trout
Feathermoon Server
Order of the White Tower

Reply

In general, I never tip. If it's something requiring reputation to make, I'll throw in a few extra pieces of the material, or a few extra dusts/shards for enchanters. But as a rule, I never accept tips on my crafting either. I flat out refuse to accept tips. (I'm an Elemental LW/Gnomish Engineer, and get a fair bit of work.)

The way I look at it, you don't deserve to make money for pressing a button. Things requiring the black forge, though, should give both a tip and a clear to the forge. You're taking more than just a minute or so from the person's time.

Reply

Rogues you should tip, or you could buy keys, or level up smithing and make them yourselves.. but they don't always work for the level of box you are trying to open.

Reply

Trout

thats a great idea

Reply

I did a fiery enchant last not and got 20s for it. I must say, I felt a little heartbroken

Reply

As a 60 rogue, it's nice to get a tip for opening a lockbox, but not necessary. If the person is from my guild, I never accept tips, even if they try. But if someone tosses in some silver for opening a difficult lockbox, then great! It was a PITA to skill up lockpicking to 300, so I appreciate it.

The biggest annoyance is when somebody asks you to open a lockbox and then they just keeping opening trades with you for more and more lockboxes. The other night somebody did about 10 in a row, tipping me 10s each lockpick. I don't care about the money, just tell me how many you have ahead of time, jeesh!

Reply

since there are so many different ways people tip how would you ever know if youre tipping enough? its kinda hard to apply the 15% rule to all the different things you can tip for in wow.

Reply

as a rule i will not take mony for low level enchanting how aver once im doing enchant that are in the 200-300 a little some thing is always nice. no charge for my guild, a good leader knows to take care of his troops.

Reply

I forgot to tip a guy for my +55healing to Benediction, and mailed him 15g afterwards. I always wonder if he was pleasantly surprised or smug when he got the tip. You know, was he like, "Oh sweet, he didn't have to do that." Or was he like, "FFS he better have tipped me GD it's about time!"

Reply

I'm a lock so when I need help with a summon I always tip- even for just clickers. I usually try and find low levels and give them 50s or so. It is nice to be declined on a tip though- but as a rule I feel the offer must always be there. After all, when I'm asked to do a summon I like tips.

Reply

How about someone makes a "Tipster" addon for wow. (bit overboard i know) but seriously, give a little "if crafted for you, expected tip should be..." to set fair amounts for crafted items. Someone get on this

Reply

I usually tip 1g for opening lock boxes and 1g for portals.

Beyond those I usually tip approximately 1% based on the value of the item, and not less than 1g.

That is, of course, unless someone is making me a linen bag ;)

Reply

My personal opinion, having had a 300 Enchanter/300 Tailor on a PvE server, is that for any crafting/combining, there should not be a charge greater than that of the value of the mats. I feel this way simply because if the crafter has the mats in their possession already, then I've not caused them any work above and beyond what they have already done themselves, and IMO, paying any amount of gold above and beyond the cost of mats is ridiculous for someone to essentially just cast a spell on an item.

Now, if I'm asking for something that will cause the crafter to farm some mats (which is almost never, I either have them or they do), or travel to the opposite continent, then that would be a case where I would assist with getting the mats or pay fairly for their time, otherwise, asking for "mats +100g" for a crusader enchant or the likes, is just being greedy.

I've never crafted or enchanted an item that I charged more than the cost of mats, and generally, I charge less, even if I use my own mats. Say... 25g with my mats for a Fiery Enchant... 30g tops, or no charge with your mats.

Reply

#1 and I are on the same page here.

My Lifestealing, Agil, Crusader enchants are a (serious pain in the rear to farm for mats) and I am not gona carry all the crap in my bank. No thanks.

Bad enough I carry loads of shards.

I always setup store with: xxx xxx enchants for Tips
I have rarely been tiped below 30 gold.

OP if you really want to complain I can get the mats and charge 150g to 200g depending on the enchant.

Or you can farm the Orbs and pay 80g since im using my own shards. This enchant does cost 200g.

Really consider what you posted with a lot more thought. You think its easy to come by all the matts and or even find these rare recipes?

There is no Set Fair price cause the market fluxes on all the matts often.

Hell currently its roughly 80g per pair of Righteous orbs alone...not counting the Large shards.

I prefer working on the Tip system ...matts alone would
fill my bank up for my rare enchants. No thanks. Yet alone farming for it all..

I dont wana see Stratholme EVER again...5000 times inside is enough in my career there.

Reply

I have 7 toons on the one server covering all professions.

I need no-one so I don't tip.

On the other hand, I have a friend who plays a warrior on another server and when he is invited to a PuG his response is "Pay 4g or I don't join"

4g being his estimated repair bill after doing the instance.

Kinda like a "reverse-tip"

Reply

Bunkai 25g for fire? Is your server just gold or what?

Fire Essence on my server is 12g
Small Brill Shards are 9g a piece

Fire alone is like 40g with AH bought matts

25g? for you? WTF

Reply